| 1871 | Harry Wright+ | 3 | | Harry Wright+ | 3 | | Harry Wright+ | 3 | | Harry Wright+ | 3 |
| 1872 | Harry Wright+ | 7 | | Harry Wright+ | 4 | | Harry Wright+ | 7 | | Harry Wright+ | 4 |
| 1873 | Harry Wright+ | 11 | | Harry Wright+ | 4 | | Harry Wright+ | 11 | | Harry Wright+ | 4 |
| 1874 | Harry Wright+ | 14 | | Harry Wright+ | 4 | | Harry Wright+ | 14 | | Harry Wright+ | 3 |
| 1875 | Harry Wright+ | 14 | | Al Spalding+ | 9 | | Al Spalding+ | 12 | | Al Spalding+ | 9 |
|
| 1876 | Harry Wright+ | 14 | | Jack Manning | 5 | | Al Spalding+ | 12 | | Jack Manning | 5 |
| 1877 | Harry Wright+ | 14 | | Jack Manning | 5 | | Al Spalding+ | 13 | | Cal McVey | 2 |
| 1878 | Harry Wright+ | 14 | | Jack Manning | 5 | | Jack Manning | 12 | | Tom Healey | 1 |
| 1879 | Harry Wright+ | 14 | | Jack Manning | 5 | | Cal McVey | 5 | | Monte Ward+ Bobby Mathews | 1 |
| 1880 | Harry Wright+ | 14 | | Jack Manning | 5 | | Lee Richmond | 3 | | Lee Richmond | 3 |
| 1881 | Harry Wright+ | 14 | | Jack Manning | 5 | | Lee Richmond Bobby Mathews | 3 | | Bobby Mathews | 2 |
| 1882 | Harry Wright+ | 14 | | Jack Manning | 5 | | Bobby Mathews Lee Richmond Monte Ward+ | 3 | | Monte Ward+ Eddie Fusselback | 1 |
| 1883 | Harry Wright+ | 14 | | Jack Manning | 5 | | Monte Ward+ Lee Richmond Bobby Mathews | 3 | | Jim Whitney Stump Wiedman | 2 |
| 1884 | Harry Wright+ | 14 | | Jack Manning | 5 | | Billy Taylor | 4 | | Billy Taylor | 4 |
| 1885 | Harry Wright+ | 14 | | Jack Manning | 5 | | Billy Taylor Oyster Burns | 4 | | Oyster Burns | 3 |
| 1886 | Harry Wright+ | 14 | | Jack Manning | 5 | | Billy Taylor Oyster Burns | 4 | | Charlie Ferguson | 2 |
| 1887 | Harry Wright+ | 14 | | Jack Manning | 5 | | Charlie Ferguson Adonis Terry Oyster Burns Billy Taylor | 4 | | Adonis Terry | 3 |
| 1888 | Harry Wright+ | 14 | | Jack Manning | 5 | | Adonis Terry Oyster Burns | 4 | | George Wood | 2 |
| 1889 | Harry Wright+ | 14 | | Jack Manning Tony Mullane | 5 | | Tony Mullane | 7 | | Tony Mullane | 5 |
| 1890 | Harry Wright+ | 14 | | Tony Mullane Jack Manning | 5 | | Tony Mullane | 8 | | Herb Goodall | 4 |
| 1891 | Harry Wright+ | 14 | | Tony Mullane Jack Manning | 5 | | Tony Mullane | 8 | | Kid Nichols+ John Clarkson+ Joe Neale | 3 |
| 1892 | Harry Wright+ | 14 | | Jack Manning Tony Mullane | 5 | | Tony Mullane | 9 | | Gus Weyhing | 3 |
| 1893 | Harry Wright+ | 14 | | Tony Mullane Jack Manning | 5 | | Tony Mullane | 11 | | Frank Dwyer Tony Mullane Frank Donnelly Tom Colcolough Mark Baldwin | 2 |
| 1894 | Tony Mullane | 15 | | Tony Mullane Jack Manning | 5 | | Tony Mullane | 15 | | Tony Mullane | 4 |
| 1895 | Tony Mullane | 15 | | Tony Mullane Jack Manning | 5 | | Kid Nichols+ | 7 | | Ernie Beam Kid Nichols+ Tom Parrott | 3 |
| 1896 | Tony Mullane | 15 | | Jack Manning Tony Mullane | 5 | | Kid Nichols+ | 8 | | Cy Young+ | 3 |
| 1897 | Tony Mullane | 15 | | Jack Manning Tony Mullane | 5 | | Kid Nichols+ | 11 | | Kid Nichols+ Win Mercer | 3 |
| 1898 | Tony Mullane Kid Nichols+ | 15 | | Jack Manning Tony Mullane | 5 | | Kid Nichols+ | 15 | | Kid Nichols+ | 4 |
| 1899 | Kid Nichols+ | 16 | | Jack Manning Tony Mullane | 5 | | Kid Nichols+ | 16 | | Sam Leever | 3 |
| 1900 | Kid Nichols+ | 16 | | Jack Manning Tony Mullane | 5 | | Kid Nichols+ | 16 | | Frank Kitson | 4 |
| 1901 | Kid Nichols+ | 16 | | Tony Mullane Jack Manning | 5 | | Kid Nichols+ | 16 | | Bill Hoffer Jack Powell Bill Donovan | 3 |
| 1902 | Kid Nichols+ | 16 | | Jack Manning Tony Mullane | 5 | | Kid Nichols+ | 16 | | Vic Willis+ | 3 |
| 1903 | Kid Nichols+ | 16 | | Jack Manning Tony Mullane | 5 | | Kid Nichols+ | 16 | | Carl Lundgren Roscoe Miller | 3 |
| 1904 | Kid Nichols+ | 17 | | Tony Mullane Jack Manning Joe McGinnity+ | 5 | | Kid Nichols+ | 17 | | Joe McGinnity+ | 5 |
| 1905 | Kid Nichols+ | 17 | | Claude Elliott | 6 | | Kid Nichols+ | 17 | | Claude Elliott | 6 |
| 1906 | Kid Nichols+ | 17 | | Cecil Ferguson | 7 | | Kid Nichols+ | 17 | | Cecil Ferguson | 7 |
| 1907 | Joe McGinnity+ | 19 | | Cecil Ferguson | 7 | | Joe McGinnity+ | 19 | | Bill Dinneen Joe McGinnity+ Tom Hughes Ed Walsh+ | 4 |
| 1908 | Joe McGinnity+ | 24 | | Cecil Ferguson | 7 | | Joe McGinnity+ | 24 | | Ed Walsh+ | 6 |
| 1909 | Joe McGinnity+ | 24 | | Frank Arellanes | 8 | | Mordecai Brown+ Hooks Wiltse | 19 | | Frank Arellanes | 8 |
| 1910 | Mordecai Brown+ | 26 | | Frank Arellanes | 8 | | Mordecai Brown+ | 26 | | Mordecai Brown+ Harry Gaspar | 7 |
| 1911 | Mordecai Brown+ | 39 | | Mordecai Brown+ | 13 | | Mordecai Brown+ | 39 | | Mordecai Brown+ | 13 |
| 1912 | Mordecai Brown+ | 39 | | Mordecai Brown+ | 13 | | Mordecai Brown+ | 39 | | Ed Walsh+ | 10 |
| 1913 | Mordecai Brown+ | 45 | | Chief Bender+ Mordecai Brown+ | 13 | | Mordecai Brown+ | 45 | | Chief Bender+ | 13 |
| 1914 | Mordecai Brown+ | 45 | | Chief Bender+ Mordecai Brown+ | 13 | | Mordecai Brown+ | 45 | | Slim Sallee Dave Davenport Russ Ford Red Ames | 6 |
| 1915 | Mordecai Brown+ | 49 | | Chief Bender+ Mordecai Brown+ | 13 | | Mordecai Brown+ | 49 | | Hugh Bedient | 10 |
| 1916 | Mordecai Brown+ | 49 | | Mordecai Brown+ Chief Bender+ | 13 | | Mordecai Brown+ | 49 | | Red Ames Bob Shawkey | 8 |
| 1917 | Mordecai Brown+ | 49 | | Chief Bender+ Mordecai Brown+ | 13 | | Ed Walsh+ | 35 | | Dave Danforth | 9 |
| 1918 | Mordecai Brown+ | 49 | | Chief Bender+ Mordecai Brown+ | 13 | | Chief Bender+ Red Ames | 34 | | George Mogridge | 7 |
| 1919 | Mordecai Brown+ | 49 | | Chief Bender+ Mordecai Brown+ | 13 | | Red Ames | 36 | | Jim Shaw Bob Shawkey Allen Russell | 5 |
| 1920 | Mordecai Brown+ | 49 | | Chief Bender+ Mordecai Brown+ | 13 | | Slim Sallee Chief Bender+ | 34 | | Bill Sherdel | 6 |
| 1921 | Mordecai Brown+ | 49 | | Chief Bender+ Mordecai Brown+ | 13 | | Slim Sallee | 36 | | Jim Middleton Lou North Carl Mays | 7 |
| 1922 | Mordecai Brown+ | 49 | | Mordecai Brown+ Chief Bender+ | 13 | | Chief Bender+ | 34 | | Sad Sam Jones | 8 |
| 1923 | Mordecai Brown+ | 49 | | Mordecai Brown+ Chief Bender+ | 13 | | Walter Johnson+ Chief Bender+ | 34 | | Allen Russell | 9 |
| 1924 | Mordecai Brown+ | 49 | | Firpo Marberry | 15 | | Allen Russell | 40 | | Firpo Marberry | 15 |
| 1925 | Mordecai Brown+ | 49 | | Firpo Marberry | 15 | | Allen Russell | 42 | | Firpo Marberry | 15 |
| 1926 | Firpo Marberry | 52 | | Firpo Marberry | 22 | | Firpo Marberry | 52 | | Firpo Marberry | 22 |
| 1927 | Firpo Marberry | 61 | | Firpo Marberry | 22 | | Firpo Marberry | 61 | | Garland Braxton Wilcy Moore | 13 |
| 1928 | Firpo Marberry | 64 | | Firpo Marberry | 22 | | Firpo Marberry | 64 | | Waite Hoyt+ | 8 |
| 1929 | Firpo Marberry | 75 | | Firpo Marberry | 22 | | Firpo Marberry | 75 | | Firpo Marberry | 11 |
| 1930 | Firpo Marberry | 76 | | Firpo Marberry | 22 | | Firpo Marberry | 76 | | Lefty Grove+ | 9 |
| 1931 | Firpo Marberry | 83 | | Firpo Marberry | 22 | | Firpo Marberry | 83 | | Jack Quinn | 15 |
| 1932 | Firpo Marberry | 96 | | Firpo Marberry | 22 | | Firpo Marberry | 96 | | Firpo Marberry | 13 |
| 1933 | Firpo Marberry | 98 | | Firpo Marberry | 22 | | Firpo Marberry | 98 | | Jack Russell | 13 |
| 1934 | Firpo Marberry | 101 | | Firpo Marberry | 22 | | Firpo Marberry | 101 | | Carl Hubbell+ | 8 |
| 1935 | Firpo Marberry | 101 | | Firpo Marberry | 22 | | Firpo Marberry | 101 | | Dutch Leonard | 8 |
| 1936 | Firpo Marberry | 101 | | Firpo Marberry | 22 | | Firpo Marberry | 101 | | Dizzy Dean+ | 11 |
| 1937 | Firpo Marberry | 101 | | Firpo Marberry | 22 | | Lefty Grove+ | 54 | | Clint Brown | 18 |
| 1938 | Firpo Marberry | 101 | | Firpo Marberry | 22 | | Lefty Grove+ | 55 | | Dick Coffman | 12 |
| 1939 | Firpo Marberry | 101 | | Firpo Marberry | 22 | | Lefty Grove+ | 55 | | Johnny Murphy | 19 |
| 1940 | Firpo Marberry | 101 | | Firpo Marberry | 22 | | Johnny Murphy | 63 | | Al Benton | 17 |
| 1941 | Firpo Marberry | 101 | | Firpo Marberry | 22 | | Johnny Murphy | 78 | | Johnny Murphy | 15 |
| 1942 | Firpo Marberry | 101 | | Firpo Marberry | 22 | | Johnny Murphy | 89 | | Hugh Casey | 13 |
| 1943 | Firpo Marberry | 101 | | Firpo Marberry | 22 | | Johnny Murphy | 97 | | Gordon Maltzberger | 14 |
| 1944 | Firpo Marberry | 101 | | Firpo Marberry | 22 | | Johnny Murphy | 97 | | Ace Adams | 13 |
| 1945 | Firpo Marberry | 101 | | Firpo Marberry | 22 | | Johnny Murphy | 97 | | Andy Karl Ace Adams | 15 |
| 1946 | Johnny Murphy | 104 | | Firpo Marberry | 22 | | Johnny Murphy | 104 | | Bob Klinger | 9 |
| 1947 | Johnny Murphy | 107 | | Firpo Marberry | 22 | | Johnny Murphy | 107 | | Hugh Casey | 18 |
| 1948 | Johnny Murphy | 107 | | Firpo Marberry | 22 | | Hugh Casey | 50 | | Harry Gumbert Russ Christopher | 17 |
| 1949 | Johnny Murphy | 107 | | Joe Page | 27 | | Joe Page | 63 | | Joe Page | 27 |
| 1950 | Johnny Murphy | 107 | | Joe Page | 27 | | Joe Page | 76 | | Jim Konstanty | 22 |
| 1951 | Johnny Murphy | 107 | | Joe Page | 27 | | Joe Page | 76 | | Ellis Kinder | 14 |
| 1952 | Johnny Murphy | 107 | | Joe Page | 27 | | Joe Page | 76 | | Al Brazle | 16 |
| 1953 | Johnny Murphy | 107 | | Joe Page Ellis Kinder | 27 | | Joe Page | 76 | | Ellis Kinder | 27 |
| 1954 | Johnny Murphy | 107 | | Joe Page Ellis Kinder | 27 | | Joe Page | 76 | | Jim Hughes | 24 |
| 1955 | Johnny Murphy | 107 | | Ellis Kinder Joe Page | 27 | | Ellis Kinder | 93 | | Ray Narleski | 19 |
| 1956 | Johnny Murphy | 107 | | Ellis Kinder Joe Page | 27 | | Ellis Kinder | 102 | | Clem Labine | 19 |
| 1957 | Johnny Murphy | 107 | | Joe Page Ellis Kinder | 27 | | Ellis Kinder | 102 | | Bob Grim | 19 |
| 1958 | Johnny Murphy | 107 | | Ellis Kinder Joe Page | 27 | | Clem Labine | 73 | | Roy Face Ryne Duren | 20 |
| 1959 | Johnny Murphy | 107 | | Ellis Kinder Joe Page | 27 | | Clem Labine | 82 | | Don McMahon Lindy McDaniel Turk Lown | 15 |
| 1960 | Johnny Murphy | 107 | | Joe Page Ellis Kinder | 27 | | Clem Labine | 88 | | Lindy McDaniel | 26 |
| 1961 | Johnny Murphy | 107 | | Luis Arroyo | 29 | | Clem Labine | 96 | | Luis Arroyo | 29 |
| 1962 | Roy Face | 120 | | Luis Arroyo | 29 | | Roy Face | 120 | | Roy Face | 28 |
| 1963 | Roy Face | 136 | | Luis Arroyo | 29 | | Roy Face | 136 | | Stu Miller | 27 |
| 1964 | Hoyt Wilhelm+ | 146 | | Dick Radatz Luis Arroyo | 29 | | Hoyt Wilhelm+ | 146 | | Dick Radatz | 29 |
| 1965 | Hoyt Wilhelm+ | 166 | | Ted Abernathy | 31 | | Hoyt Wilhelm+ | 166 | | Ted Abernathy | 31 |
| 1966 | Hoyt Wilhelm+ | 172 | | Jack Aker | 32 | | Hoyt Wilhelm+ | 172 | | Jack Aker | 32 |
| 1967 | Hoyt Wilhelm+ | 184 | | Jack Aker | 32 | | Hoyt Wilhelm+ | 184 | | Ted Abernathy | 28 |
| 1968 | Hoyt Wilhelm+ | 196 | | Jack Aker | 32 | | Hoyt Wilhelm+ | 196 | | Phil Regan | 25 |
| 1969 | Hoyt Wilhelm+ | 210 | | Jack Aker | 32 | | Hoyt Wilhelm+ | 210 | | Ron Perranoski | 31 |
| 1970 | Hoyt Wilhelm+ | 223 | | Wayne Granger | 35 | | Hoyt Wilhelm+ | 223 | | Wayne Granger | 35 |
| 1971 | Hoyt Wilhelm+ | 226 | | Wayne Granger | 35 | | Hoyt Wilhelm+ | 226 | | Ken Sanders | 31 |
| 1972 | Hoyt Wilhelm+ | 227 | | Clay Carroll | 37 | | Hoyt Wilhelm+ | 227 | | Clay Carroll | 37 |
| 1973 | Hoyt Wilhelm+ | 227 | | John Hiller | 38 | | Ron Perranoski | 179 | | John Hiller | 38 |
| 1974 | Hoyt Wilhelm+ | 227 | | John Hiller | 38 | | Lindy McDaniel | 171 | | Terry Forster | 24 |
| 1975 | Hoyt Wilhelm+ | 227 | | John Hiller | 38 | | Lindy McDaniel | 172 | | Rich Gossage+ | 26 |
| 1976 | Hoyt Wilhelm+ | 227 | | John Hiller | 38 | | Sparky Lyle | 175 | | Rawly Eastwick | 26 |
| 1977 | Hoyt Wilhelm+ | 227 | | John Hiller | 38 | | Sparky Lyle | 201 | | Rollie Fingers+ | 35 |
| 1978 | Hoyt Wilhelm+ | 227 | | John Hiller | 38 | | Sparky Lyle | 210 | | Rollie Fingers+ | 37 |
| 1979 | Hoyt Wilhelm+ | 227 | | John Hiller | 38 | | Sparky Lyle | 223 | | Bruce Sutter+ | 37 |
| 1980 | Rollie Fingers+ | 244 | | John Hiller | 38 | | Rollie Fingers+ | 244 | | Dan Quisenberry Rich Gossage+ | 33 |
| 1981 | Rollie Fingers+ | 272 | | John Hiller | 38 | | Rollie Fingers+ | 272 | | Rollie Fingers+ | 28 |
| 1982 | Rollie Fingers+ | 301 | | John Hiller | 38 | | Rollie Fingers+ | 301 | | Bruce Sutter+ | 36 |
| 1983 | Rollie Fingers+ | 301 | | Dan Quisenberry | 45 | | Rollie Fingers+ | 301 | | Dan Quisenberry | 45 |
| 1984 | Rollie Fingers+ | 324 | | Dan Quisenberry Bruce Sutter+ | 45 | | Rollie Fingers+ | 324 | | Bruce Sutter+ | 45 |
| 1985 | Rollie Fingers+ | 341 | | Bruce Sutter+ Dan Quisenberry | 45 | | Rollie Fingers+ | 341 | | Jeff Reardon | 41 |
| 1986 | Rollie Fingers+ | 341 | | Dave Righetti | 46 | | Bruce Sutter+ | 286 | | Dave Righetti | 46 |
| 1987 | Rollie Fingers+ | 341 | | Dave Righetti | 46 | | Rich Gossage+ | 289 | | Steve Bedrosian | 40 |
| 1988 | Rollie Fingers+ | 341 | | Dave Righetti | 46 | | Rich Gossage+ | 302 | | Dennis Eckersley+ | 45 |
| 1989 | Rollie Fingers+ | 341 | | Dave Righetti | 46 | | Rich Gossage+ | 307 | | Mark Davis | 44 |
| 1990 | Rollie Fingers+ | 341 | | Bobby Thigpen | 57 | | Rich Gossage+ | 307 | | Bobby Thigpen | 57 |
| 1991 | Rollie Fingers+ | 341 | | Bobby Thigpen | 57 | | Jeff Reardon | 327 | | Lee Smith | 47 |
| 1992 | Jeff Reardon | 357 | | Bobby Thigpen | 57 | | Jeff Reardon | 357 | | Dennis Eckersley+ | 51 |
| 1993 | Lee Smith | 401 | | Bobby Thigpen | 57 | | Lee Smith | 401 | | Randy Myers | 53 |
| 1994 | Lee Smith | 434 | | Bobby Thigpen | 57 | | Lee Smith | 434 | | Lee Smith | 33 |
| 1995 | Lee Smith | 471 | | Bobby Thigpen | 57 | | Lee Smith | 471 | | Jose Mesa | 46 |
| 1996 | Lee Smith | 473 | | Bobby Thigpen | 57 | | Lee Smith | 473 | | Todd Worrell Jeff Brantley | 44 |
| 1997 | Lee Smith | 478 | | Bobby Thigpen | 57 | | Lee Smith | 478 | | Randy Myers | 45 |
| 1998 | Lee Smith | 478 | | Bobby Thigpen | 57 | | John Franco | 397 | | Trevor Hoffman | 53 |
| 1999 | Lee Smith | 478 | | Bobby Thigpen | 57 | | John Franco | 416 | | Mariano Rivera | 45 |
| 2000 | Lee Smith | 478 | | Bobby Thigpen | 57 | | John Franco | 420 | | Antonio Alfonseca | 45 |
| 2001 | Lee Smith | 478 | | Bobby Thigpen | 57 | | John Franco | 422 | | Mariano Rivera | 50 |
| 2002 | Lee Smith | 478 | | Bobby Thigpen | 57 | | John Franco | 422 | | John Smoltz | 55 |
| 2003 | Lee Smith | 478 | | Bobby Thigpen | 57 | | John Franco | 424 | | Eric Gagne | 55 |
| 2004 | Lee Smith | 478 | | Bobby Thigpen | 57 | | John Franco | 424 | | Mariano Rivera | 53 |
| 2005 | Lee Smith | 478 | | Bobby Thigpen | 57 | | Trevor Hoffman | 436 | | Chad Cordero | 47 |
| 2006 | Trevor Hoffman | 482 | | Bobby Thigpen | 57 | | Trevor Hoffman | 482 | | Francisco Rodriguez | 47 |
| 2007 | Trevor Hoffman | 524 | | Bobby Thigpen | 57 | | Trevor Hoffman | 524 | | Jose Valverde | 47 |
| 2008 | Trevor Hoffman | 554 | | Francisco Rodriguez | 62 | | Trevor Hoffman | 554 | | Francisco Rodriguez | 62 |
| 2009 | Trevor Hoffman | 591 | | Francisco Rodriguez | 62 | | Trevor Hoffman | 591 | | Brian Fuentes | 48 |
| 2010 | Trevor Hoffman | 601 | | Francisco Rodriguez | 62 | | Trevor Hoffman | 601 | | Brian Wilson | 48 |
| 2011 | Mariano Rivera | 603 | | Francisco Rodriguez | 62 | | Mariano Rivera | 603 | | Jose Valverde | 49 |
| 2012 | Mariano Rivera | 608 | | Francisco Rodriguez | 62 | | Mariano Rivera | 608 | | Jim Johnson | 51 |
| 2013 | Mariano Rivera | 624 | | Francisco Rodriguez | 62 | | Mariano Rivera | 624 | | Jason Grilli | 17 |