| Most-Seasons | Willie Mays-7 Babe Ruth-7 Walter Johnson-6 Cy Young-5 Barry Bonds-5
| Christy Mathewson-4 Babe Ruth-4 Stan Musial-3 Hank Aaron-3 Randy Johnson-3
| Duke Snider-4 Cy Young-4 Roger Clemens-3 Rogers Hornsby-3 Lou Gehrig-3
| Hank Aaron-4 Stan Musial-3 Tris Speaker-3 Chase Utley-3 Wes Ferrell-3
| Jim Bunning-3 Mel Ott-2 Johnny Bench-2 Dick McBride-2 Vida Blue-2
| Eddie Mathews-4 Bert Blyleven-3 George Zettlein-2 Ken Boyer-2 Bill Hoffer-2
| Tris Speaker-2 Walter Johnson-2 Al Simmons-2 Bucky Walters-2 Hank Aaron-2
| Mike Schmidt-3 Christy Mathewson-2 Mel Ott-2 Tris Speaker-2 Roger Clemens-2
| Ed Delahanty-3 Eddie Plank-3 Tris Speaker-2 Bob Shawkey-2 Paul Waner-2
| Tim Keefe-3 Cap Anson-3 Bill Bradley-3 Hank Aaron-2 Andruw Jones-2
|